Counting the Cost of Condemnation – A Homily for the 5th Sunday of Lent

This Sunday’s Mass features the well-known Gospel of the woman caught in adultery. In it, the Lord intimates to the men of His day that the severe punishment they want to mete out to this woman may be unwise given that they themselves must prepare for their own judgment.

Before we examine the details, let’s consider a few background texts that may help us to better understand what Jesus is teaching. After each verse, I provide a brief commentary in red.

  • Blessed are the merciful, for they will be shown mercy (Matt 5:7). Notice that it is the merciful who will obtain mercy. Those who have shown proper mercy will be granted mercy on the Day of Judgment. By implication, the severe and merciless will be judged severely by the Lord.
  • Do not condemn, and you will not be condemned. Forgive, and you will be forgiven. Give, and it will be given to you. A good measure, pressed down, shaken together and running over, will be poured into your lap. For with the measure you use, it will be measured to you (Luke 6:37-38). The text clearly states that if we use a severe standard of judgment, that same strict standard will be used by the Lord when He judges us. On the other hand, if we are forgiving, merciful, and generous then we can expect a merciful, generous, and kind judgment from God.
  • Speak and act as those who are going to be judged under the law of freedom, for judgment without mercy will be shown to anyone who has not been merciful. Mercy triumphs over judgment (James 2:12-13). James gives us three warnings. First, he reminds us that we are going to be judged by the Lord. Second, he intimates that because we are free, we are responsible for what we do. Third, because we are going to face this judgment, in which we will not be able to blame others for what we have freely done, we’d better realize that our judgment will be without mercy if we have not shown mercy. Conversely, if we have shown mercy then we stand a chance on our own judgment day, for mercy will triumph over strict judgment.
  • For if you forgive men when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive men their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins (Mat 6:14-15). This warning seems clear enough: if we want to find forgiveness on the Day of Judgment, we had better seek the grace to forgive others.

All these texts teach the bold truth that we can influence the standard against which the Lord will measure us on the day of our judgment. The measure we use for others will be measured back to us. If we have been merciful then we will find mercy, but if we have been harsh, unbending, and unmerciful, the Lord will judge us far more strictly.

We need to be sober about this. We are storing up things for the Day of Judgment by the way we treat others. Because we are all going to need so much mercy and because we cannot endure strict standards of judgment, we should consider carefully the need to be merciful and forgiving to others. And now, on to today’s Gospel!

I. COLLABORATORS IN CONDEMNATION – The Pharisees and the teachers of the law bring forward a woman caught in the act of adultery. (There is something curious about this, though: If she was caught in the act, the man involved must also be known. Why has he not be brought forward? The Law of Moses indicates that the man should be stoned as well.)

The accusers want to “throw the book” at her. They want the strictest punishment meted out: stoning. They also hope to discredit Jesus by putting Him in what they think is a no-win situation.

In their accusatory stance, they have become collaborators with Satan. Scripture describes Satan in this way: the accuser of our brethren has been thrown down, who accuses them day and night before our God (Rev 12:10). Thus, these Pharisees, in seeking to hand her over, join Satan.

When we have been hurt in some way, many of us may wish to both accuse and demand punishment of the person before God; this is unnecessary and unwise.

It is unnecessary because Satan is already accusing them “day and night” before God. In addition, God sees and knows all things anyway!

It is unwise because by demanding harsh punishment for others we set ourselves up to judged by the same strict standard. It’s always a better policy to cry for grace and the conversion of sinners.

II. COUNTING THE COST – As God, Jesus knows the sins of all the men gathered. He must be amazed; surely, they cannot be serious in demanding such a harsh punishment for the woman knowing that the day of their own judgment awaits!

Jesus bends down and traces His finger on the ground, almost as if tracing along with the words of a book He is reading about their deeds. Some suggest that perhaps He is writing down their sins. Some liken it to the finger of God tracing the commandments on stone. Still others recall the mysterious hand in the Book of Daniel, which traces the words MENE, TEKEL, PERES on the wall, announcing doom to the Babylonian king.

Whatever the case, it isn’t good. You don’t ever want Jesus to be writing things down about you!

These Pharisees are slow to appreciate the significance of the gesture, so Jesus tries to reason with them, saying,Let him among you who is without sin cast the first stone.” Then He bends down again and continues writing on the ground.

It is almost as though Jesus were saying,

Reason with me, men. If you demand strict justice, if you insist that I “throw the book” at her, you’d better first look and see what is written about you in “the book.” If she is to be judged strictly and without mercy, then you, too, will face the same standard.

Gentlemen, there are things in the book about you—serious things. Have you counted the cost of condemning this woman? Are you sure that you want to demand that I “throw the book” at her?

Think about it, men. Think very carefully.

One by one they go away. It begins with the older men, who are presumably less rash than the younger ones (and may well have committed more sins).

The message for us is clear: we will face judgment. We need to be sober about this. We must count the cost of being unmerciful, unforgiving, and vengeful. The measure that we measure out to others will be the measure that God uses for us.

What kind of judgment are you preparing for yourself? Condemnation comes at a high cost. Are you willing to risk storing up wrath and strict justice for the day of your own judgment?

On the other hand, gentleness, compassionate correction, and merciful love will also be given to us if we show it to others. Remember your upcoming judgment. Be like the wise man, who knows he will need grace and mercy on that day because he will not be able to withstand a strict adjudication of his crimes.

III. CORRECTING WITH COMPASSION – The departure of the accusers leaves Jesus alone with the woman. Though He speaks gently, Jesus is clear: “Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?” She replied, “No one, sir.” Then Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go, and from now on do not sin anymore.”

This Gospel, therefore, does not make light of the woman’s sin. Jesus knows what she has done and so does she. He is clear that she must turn away from sin; she must not commit it anymore. What Jesus does set aside is the condemning “hang-’em-high” mentality that seeks the harshest measures for every situation.

Yes, we must sometimes correct sinners and mete out punishment. This is particularly true if we are a parent, a juror, or someone in a supervisory role.

Before rushing to extreme measures, however, we do well to show mercy and to attempt lesser measures first.

St. Paul has good advice: Brothers, if someone is caught in a sin, you who are spiritual should gently set him right. But watch yourself, or you also may be tempted (Gal 6:1).

Gentle and clear correction is the best course. More significant punishments should only be a later recourse. We must be careful not to be tempted to harshness, anger, mercilessness, and lovelessness.

OK, you get the point: count the cost. Be very careful to remember that the measure you measure out to others will be measured out to you. Blessed are the merciful for they shall obtain mercy.

6 Replies to “Counting the Cost of Condemnation – A Homily for the 5th Sunday of Lent”

  1. The inspired text expressly states that the men wanted to trap Jesus into taking the execution of capital punishment into His own hands. But the Romans had removed that power from the Jewish courts. These could still try capital cases and pronounce death sentences, and for all we know they had done so in this case. For Jesus to have commanded the woman to be put to death would have led to His denunciation to the Roman authorities.

  2. In this day in age, take a moment to reflect on the scene described. It seems that the Pharisees had whipped up a “mob” and hoped to get Jesus caught up in their irrational emotions. Amazingly Jesus finds the perfect path to deflect their “righteous” anger and bitter zeal.

    We need more of this in today’s society. Over-supply of mob-inciters. Under-supply of mob-dispersers.

  3. Msgr. Pope’s comments are well worth taking to heart, because we all have a tendency to judge harshly and rashly. It is important to realize, though that the Gospel passage is not meant to get us to stop making judgments altogether: In just the prior chapter, John tells us to “judge righteously” instead of improperly, so he can hardly mean “stop judging”. St. Thomas clarifies this by saying that the judge (i.e. one whose proper role requires judgment) should, FIRST, cleanse himself of sin by confession and penance, become righteous before God (by God’s grace, not his own), and then judge according to the righteousness of God. “Take the beam out of your own eye, first, and then you will see…” etc.

    Also, an important element is that Christ was, in refusing to condemn the woman, strictly following the Law. See my essay on this at: http://whatswrongwiththeworld.net/2018/03/the_woman_caught_in_adultery.html

  4. I’ve always been rather/somewhat confused about what exactly is meant by “do not judge, do not ‘judge’.”

    But considering the context – that the Jews of Jesus’ time acted as actual judges ones over the others even in moral matters, condemning people to death even for the committing of adultery –, it probably means: “do not rush to execute or to shun, not even to beat or to insult (cf. Matt. 5:22), people who have sinned (or are sinning) in this or that way.”

    (It doesn’t mean “don’t say ‘sin’ to sin;” nor the less extreme: “don’t tell to any people who are sinning that they’re sinning.”)

  5. Incredible wisdom given to us through God’s only son. How appropriate, relevant, and timely has this ancient text been throughout the ages, and now examines our own conscience in a world filled with temptation and sin. We should all love the Beatitudes and allow them to speak to our hearts every day. We are commanded to be merciful and if we obey, then our reward is mercy. God’s simple message and teaching is easy and the burden light. We only need to be faithful in rejecting wrath, greed, lust, envy, pride, sloth, and gluttony. God gives us the tools to “fix” our sin by Jesus’ commandments to love God with all that we are and to love our neighbors as we love ourselves. With generosity, prudence, grace, humility, diligence, and temperance, forgiveness can be attained through prayer. Fear of God and love of Christ all taken in the same breath leads to beauty and happiness and joy. Embrace the goodness provided and turn away from the sin that chains you. Free yourself with confession, make your chin like stone against the sins that plague us.

  6. That’s a rather prolix version of a story that was not even in the account written by John. My American Standard Version, © 1901, includes the passage, but with this caveat in a footnote.
    “Most of the ancient authorities omit John 7:53 – 8:11. Those which contain it vary much from each other.”

    There are other, authentic, passages in scripture that illustrate Yahweh’s mercy. I like the passage in Isaiah 55, beginning with v. 7. Matthew 18:23 ff. Is also comforting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.