A Lament on the Shrinking of Summer

Not so long ago the middle of August was still a lazy time to enjoy the last few days of summer. It used to be that Labor Day marked the unofficial end of summer—not so much any more in more places for more and more people.

The erosion of summer is driven mainly by the start of school. I have watched with sadness as the school year seems to begin earlier and earlier and earlier. In the Washington, D.C. area, parents are young people are preparing for that first day of school – and some schools have already started. College classes start even earlier, early August in some cases; and new students who need an “orientation” generally arrive on campus even before the general student population.

What’s the big rush? Why are some people in such a big hurry to get back to the grind? Families have so little time to spend time together as it is! I hope that the concerns I express today will be seen as having spiritual components and not just as the complaints of an old curmudgeon.

The purpose of rest, both the Sabbath rest and vacation, is to enjoy the fruit of our labors. We should work to live; many today live to work. What is the point of having a livelihood if we never get the time to enjoy life? God commanded the Sabbath for many reasons, but among them was justice. He set forth a particular day of the week (Saturday) as well as other times (feasts) when work was forbidden so that all could rest. Without the collective agreement and commandment (under pain of sin), the rich get time off but the poor must still work to facilitate the leisure of the rich. God set forth a system that sought to prevent that injustice. All, including slaves and even beasts of burden, were to refrain from all but the most necessary work.

In our culture, Sunday has been the day of rest. Most who have better paying jobs get that day off. Before 1970, even the poor typically had Sundays off because most retail establishments were closed. Today, for our convenience, lower-paid store workers and restaurant staff must work.

It is the same with holidays and holy days. It used to be that days like Christmas, Good Friday, and Thanksgiving were days off for just about everyone. Non-essential operations were generally closed.

Today almost nothing — no day, no time — is sacred. Market demand and the need to get ahead of the competition drive this. Work, work, work; compete and strive to win. It is usually the poorest among us, however, who pay the greatest price for this.

Families also suffer; time together has steadily eroded over the years. The tradition of eating evening and weekend meals is all but gone. Sunday and holiday gatherings seem to be shorter and more perfunctory—if they occur at all. Summer itself is now on the chopping block. Churches are affected because the window in which we have to conduct summer festivals and Vacation Bible school is more limited.

I have been given numerous explanations as to why schools are champing at the bit to begin the year.

School officials (in both secular and Catholic schools) tell me that many parents are delighted that their children are back in school earlier, thus freeing them to do other things rather than minding the children. But what does that tell you about the vision of family life today? Shouldn’t families want extended time to vacation together and to engage in other local activities, Church offerings, and so forth? Shouldn’t parents enjoy spending time with their children? Shouldn’t they want to use the extra time in the summer to form them? Do parents have children merely to send them off to school, happy to be rid of them for a few hours? I hope not. I know that we all get a little tired, but I find it alarming that parents would be as eager for school to start as school officials insist is the case.

I am told that teachers require more days for professional development, thus forcing schools to open earlier in the year and/or close later in order to meet the required minimum number of days of student instruction. But professional days and ongoing certification have always been necessary. My mother was a teacher for over twenty years and teachers had professional days and took certification courses (mainly in the summer) back then. Teachers already have two and a half months away from classes. That’s a lot more vacation than most of the rest of us have. Is there a reason that teachers could not have most of June and July off and then return at the beginning of August for these sorts of things? If schools opened after Labor Day that would still give them more than a month for these activities.

Further I would argue that the impact of such a system is not a good one. It sets up a “death by a thousand cuts” throughout the school year as half-days, teacher in-service days, and professional days seem to eat into most weeks of the school year. In some school systems nearly every Friday is a half day for one reason or another. Working parents must juggle schedules all year long, not just in the summer when vacations are already common. Schools even collect a lot extra money running “aftercare” programs on those half-days of classes. Parents are not only deprived of time with their children, but they are pressured financially as well.

The school system is supposed to serve children, parents, and families, but it seems instead that the school systems have started ruling our lives and dictating our schedules. Even in Catholic and other private schools, parents who are already struggling just to afford the tuition must now also pay for additional childcare on those days when school is not in session or closes early.

My final concern is that school schedules carving away more and more of the summer from family time means that the formation of children shifts from the families to the schools. Is that really what we want? I would hope that parents would want to play the most significant role in forming their children. Parents should ask themselves if they want to raise their children or increasingly hand that task over to strangers. Sadly, as we all can see, many schools have become less and less places of teaching basic academic skills and more and more places of indoctrination into values that are often inimical to Catholic and biblical teachings. Although there are exceptions, the infiltration of secular and immoral ideologies into the curriculum has made major inroads in public schools.

I recommend we attack this problem by starting simply. Can we at least have the month of August back? How about an agreement not begin school until the Tuesday after Labor Day? It’s just a little thing, but the steady erosion of rest, family time, Church time, and “downtime” has taken a toll on our society in many ways. Here’s to summer … all of it!

Cross-posted at the Catholic Standard: A Lament on the Shrinking of Summer

9 Replies to “A Lament on the Shrinking of Summer”

  1. Hello!
    We are a homeschooling family that schools on a year-round schedule, with the month of July off, time off throughout the year and holy days as well as some other days. This allows us to enjoy the weather during all of the seasons. As great as summer can be, the weather is not always enjoyable. A couple of weeks off during the fall is a delight, as is a mid-winter break and time off in the spring. I realize this might not work for everyone, but we do it this way to enjoy the seasons, not to shrink up summer. God bless you!

  2. Here in South Florida they started public school today and Catholic School starts Monday. The school’s reasoning is that they want the semester finished before Christmas break. They also want a certain amount of class time done before mandatory testing happens in the spring. I think it is more about testing than anything else.

  3. Wait until they finally get around to starting school earlier in the morning and going later in the evening, as well as starting earlier in the year and ending after Memorial Day. This is to accommodate working mothers, which I believe make up the current majority. Most of the trouble in the country right now can be attributed to working mothers.

  4. Sports practices begin long before the school year itself starts. And sports practices mean kids either get up very early for practice before school starts, or stay late into the evening practically every night. There is very little time left for family and religious education. It is very disheartening for us pastors.

  5. Honestly I’m so relieved school starts again on Monday.

    I’m not sure this is a realistic version of what life in the summertime looks like for most families.

    My husband works 50 hours a week, I work 20 hours from home (both of us for the Church, so not able to survive on a single income) we’re expecting baby number 6 in a few months, and our oldest is 9, and if I have to spend one more day breaking up fights and passing out snacks to my kids and the entire neighborhood whose parents’ absence at work has sent them wandering into my kitchen and backyard at all hours of the day, I might lose my mind.

    Raising kids in an economy and an environment like this isn’t full of quality leisure time. I love my kids dearly and I’m *so* grateful I can be at home with them, but I literally do everything for 12 or 13 hours at a stretch plus work multiple freelance jobs, and the loneliness and physical exhaustion can be crushing sometimes.

  6. I wonder if this is more of a regional thing? I live in the Philly suburbs and teach in a Catholic high school right across the bridge in New Jersey, and we don’t start school until after Labor Day; that’s what it’s like in this entire region as far as I know — and I think it should stay that way; I can’t imagine starting school in August. We do go rather late, though, into mid-June — do schools elsewhere in the country end earlier?

    1. Brendan:

      We started school in Las Vegas this week. We have first semester final exams before Christmas, and we finish the year before Memorial Day. It’s hot here all summer long, so it doesn’t really matter when “summer” is, but we certainly like finals before Christmas – it is a much needed mental break for teachers and students.

  7. We totally agree with you Father! Summer break should be a full three months!

    And that is the way we have kept it at our school here in Ohio – The Lyceum! (www.thelyceum.org)

  8. Truth be told, it’s partly the same reason why folks demand kindergarten and then pre-k. School becomes daycare when the nation is filled with single parents or dual income families for those still holding together. Any day off during the work week becomes a crisis and financial hardship.

Comments are closed.