And He Will Wipe Every Tear From Their Eyes, yes, Every Tear. A Reflection on the Healing Hope of Purgatory

Oh Lord, I’m running….Trying to make a 100. Ninety-nine and a half won’t do! These are the words of an old African American spiritual. And ultimately they are rooted in a promise of God that we will one day be perfect.

Well, I’ll tell you, God’s been good to me and he’s brought me a mighty long way, but I’m not at 100, not even close. Because this “100” is not graded on some human curve or scale. The 100 is God’s 100! Jesus says, Be therefore perfect, as also your heavenly Father is perfect (Matt 5:48).

How about you? Are you there yet?

If we’re honest we all fall short, way short. But what then of God’s promise, if on the day we die, we haven’t reached God’s 100? Have you ever really known anyone who had God’s perfection? Really? We often speak of how holy some people are, and some have reached great heights, by God’s grace. But how many have you or I really known that had, not just human perfection, but the very perfection of God?

So what if we die unfinished? And most of us will.

Some say, oh well, God will just overlook all that and let us in anyway, “God loves me just the way I am.” But again then we must ask, “What of God’s promise that we would be perfect as the heavenly Father is perfect?”

And further, what of the descriptions of the just in heaven and the promises of perfection assigned to us? For example:

  1. But you have come to Mount Zion, to the heavenly Jerusalem, the city of the living God. You have come to thousands upon thousands of angels in joyful assembly, to the church of the firstborn, whose names are written in heaven. You have come to God, the judge of all men, to the spirits of righteous men made perfect (Heb 12:22-23)
  2. I saw the Holy City, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride beautifully dressed for her husband…..Nothing impure will ever enter it, nor will anyone who does what is shameful or deceitful, but only those whose names are written in the Lamb’s book of life (Rev 21:2,27).
  3. You know that the testing of your faith develops perseverance. Perseverance must finish its work so that you may be mature and complete, and lacking in nothing. (James 1:3-4)
  4. For now, we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when the perfect comes, the partial will pass away (1 Cor 13:9-10).
  5. God who has begun a good work in you, will bring it to perfection. (Phil 1:6)

So the promise and the need of perfection stand clear in Scripture. And God will not just overlook his promise and “love me just the way I am.”

What a callous and cruel thing to consign us to ultimate imperfection. The very thought of living in my present unseemly state forever would be awful. As I have said, God has been good to me, but for all of us, there are still too many disordered and competitive drives at work, too many unruly passions, and too many spiritual, emotional and physical irritants of many unknown and deep sources, for you and me to say we’d be happy to stay in this condition. Spiritual progress is the normal Christian state.  But we are heading to a high and wondrous state beyond all imagining. This is the promise and I won’t be satisfied with anything less that the full promise of the Lord to make me perfect as the heavenly Father is perfect.

GK Chesterton, responding to a Critic of Purgatory said,

Purgatory may exist whether he likes it or not…..It may be obvious to us that [a person] is already utterly sinless, at one with the saints. It may be evident to us that [he] is already utterly selfless, filled only with God and forgetful of the very meaning of gain. But if the cosmic power holds that there are still some strange finishing touches, beyond our fancy, to put to his perfection, then certainly there will be some cosmic provision for that mysterious completion of the seemingly complete. The stars are not clean in His sight and His angels He chargeth with folly; and if [God] should decide….there is room for improvement, we can but admit that omniscience can heal the defect that we cannot even see. (G.K’s Weekly 4/11/1925)

Yes, even if we were to engage in the folly of thinking we ourselves, or someone else had reached perfection, the truth is we don’t really know what true, God-like perfection is. All I know is, that if I were to die today, God would have to bring to completion the good work he has begun in me.

The Protestants largely dismiss Purgatory because their first founders (Luther, Calvin et al.) tended to reduce salvation and justification to a legal act. The sinner was “declared” righteous, was “covered” in the blood of the Lamb. But this justice was a justitia aliena (an alien justice), a justice imputed, declared, or said of the sinner, but not intrinsic to them. They did not actually become righteous, they were merely said to be righteous and the Father overlooked their sin. They were, to use Luther’s supposed analogy, a dung hill covered with snow (but still a dung hill underneath).

But here too is a sad loss of the promise of the Lord who did not merely promise we would be considered perfect, but that we would actually BE perfect, by his grace. And in all the promises of scripture listed above, there is no notion of a mere declaration of perfection but, rather, an actual experience of real perfection, an actual and real transformation. And this experience, this transformation, begins now. But surely some finishing work is required for most all of us after death, if we take the scope of Godlike perfection seriously.

Purgatory just makes sense when we focus on the promises of God rather than merely to see it as a punitive place where we make up for our sins. Purgatory must also be a place of healing and of promise keeping. Likely there is suffering there, since to let go and be purged of things to which we have been clinging is probably not easy. But Oh, the healing too and weight that must be lifted and we finally shed years of accumulated “issues and baggage.”

Of those made fit for heaven the Scripture says that Jesus “Will wipe every tear from their eyes” (Rev 21:3). I, like you, have surely said goodbye to family, friends and parishioners who still had some tears in their eyes. And we know that they, like we, had things they could not bring to heaven: tears, sorrows, regrets, painful memories, unhealed hurts, and sins. But God, who is good, and a promise keeper, will not leave anything undone. He will wipe every tear from our eyes, every tear.

Purgatory has to be. God loves us too much to leave us in our present unseemly state.

I have written more on the Biblical Roots of Purgatory here: Purgatory – Biblical and Reasonable

Photo Credit: Spiritual Inspirations

8 Replies to “And He Will Wipe Every Tear From Their Eyes, yes, Every Tear. A Reflection on the Healing Hope of Purgatory”

  1. The journey continues! Working my way to 100! After reading your blog today am I left with thoughts on the importance of suffering. God does not send suffering to His children but He does allows it. The beauty of the suffering is that it provides us the opportunity to learn how to suffer with joy. Joy that comes in knowing Him are recognizing His presence in our suffering. Not only does it allow us to draw closer to our Father as should be our intent always, but by making it an offering to the Father it then becomes a gift of unspeakable joy. By no means, not an easy task to do, but in trusting in His promises He leads the way. Our world seems to be premature in expelling suffering from our lives thus dismissing opportunities for growth and drawing closer to the 100 mark. I have learned to embrace suffering as a gift rather than a burden. Not anything I am capable of doing on my own. It requires a healthy spiritual and prayerful life. Another challenge to overcome as the world and the Enemy continue to challenge us in counter productive ways. I turn to Him to show me the way and lead me through whatever He is allowing me to endure. He has promised to never leave me and reassures me through His promises to cast my fears away. When we consume ourselves with fear ( a great weapon used by the Enemy) our focus becomes our fear and we loose our direction.

    As Catholics we believe in the Communion of Saints. The church militant, the church suffering and the church triumphant. In calling upon one another to pray and offer sacrifices we partake in working together to reach our final destination leading us into that Heavenly Jerusalem where the tears will be wiped form our eyes and we will run along the streets of gold. We need to embrace the opportunities of suffering as Jesus taught us through the greatest sign of His love,death on a cross. As Christians suffering has been promised to us and we need to understand and remember it is the only was back home. What direction are we headed? I am seeking 100 Heaven Avenue. As His child I seem to ask frequently along the trip, “Are we there yet?”

  2. Thank you for this article, Msgr. As always, it is so necessary to connect daily with an explanation of our Catholic beliefs because they are held to be either erroneous, in the case of my Protestant family members, or outrageous, by the secularists. One can feel very alone in such an environment. By the way, is there an indulgence on this day for our deceased relatives? I recall as a very small child seeing adults going in and out of the church to say special prayers all day long on November 2. However, I have never heard it mentioned from the pulpit or in bulletins for many, many years.

  3. Do you ever read the obituaries? It seems every one that dies these day has gone “to be with the Lord”. I take that to mean they went straight to Heaven because at some point in their lives they “accepted the lord” which must have given them saint status at death. I hope I get lots and lots of prayers because I KNOW I will certainly need them… meanwhile I shall continue working on a better rating, I may be at around 80 (not close to 100) right now.

  4. Personally, I believe Purgatory is one of the most reassuring as well as logical tenets of our Catholic faith. It bridges the inevitable abyss separating even the 99.999% perfected condition of the most apparently saintly soul (on dying) from the 100% of the beatific vision. Most of us fall way below this, hence I would agree with Patt that it is unfortunate sentimentalism which makes many obituaries (implicitly) claim so many of the dead have gone straight to Heaven. It is also reassuring for us to think that we can help the poor souls in Purgatory with our prayers, and also that any soul we enable to enter heaven more speedily will undoubtedly be grateful and pray for us on earth.

  5. Each of us, examining his/her life, finds some things wrong or sinful both because of commission and because of omission. There are references in scripture, both OT and NT, to the need to clean our souls before we can be admitted to the splendid happiness of the Beatific Vision. It is a comforting thought that God cares enough for us to clean us up; but the “instant canonization” that infects most obituaries and many remarks at funerals may cause the survivors to neglect prayer for the dead. “It is therefore a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead, that they may be loosed from sins.” (II Machabees 12:45-46)

  6. Thanks for an excellent composition, Msgr. Pope–a great gift, and right down the strike zone! It fills an important place in my personal journey of faith at the moment and will help me defend our Catholic faith to those who challenge the concept of Purgatory. And what a great joy to have that wonderful promise of perfection to look forward to! Also, and as well supported by Mary Floore’s comments, your essay goes a long way to showing us the value of suffering in this life. I have been carrying the burden of Gulf War Illness for some 14 years now since it became serious and at times felt somewhat negative about the entire situation, but, at this point, having given an honest examination of myself, I have to say that I am a much better person, or rather that the goodness I had before the trials now has a greater depth and more lasting temper, having been tested so severely. God knows what he is doing, and this article goes a long way to helping us understand his methods. I pray God blesses you for your service to his Church and for going to such trouble to give us a wonderful gift of the faith. As Cardinal Suenens said in his introduction to his monograph, Renewal and the Powers of Darkness, “I wrote this in suffering.” It is never easy to produce such gifts of the faith because the Devil inevitably attacks and obstructs the gift giver, trying to prevent delivery. Many thanks for paying that price to help us.

  7. Having been a Calvinist, I now, thanks to your excellent explanation, understand things about healing and purging I could not otherwise.Thanks. But I have a question:Purgatory is for people who have died, so what happens with those who are still alive on earth when Jesus comes back to earth? Will they be healed and purified instantly,as St Paul says, “…in the twinkling of an eye”?

Comments are closed.